Morrison's Lies Meet Menzies' Shadows

Morrison's Lies Meet Menzies' Shadows

Australia's political culture has decayed from Menzies-era strategic clarity to Morrison-era deceit, and these five books trace that fall. Quarterly Essay — Australia's premier long-form political journal, published four times a year since 2001 — has documented the shift: Bernard Keane catalogs Morrison's lies, Hugh White warns of our US-China tightrope, James Brown exposes our reflexive military deployments, and George Megalogenis mourns the end of reform courage. Robert Bollard's WWI history reminds us we've been punching above our weight — and fooling ourselves about alliances — for over a century.
  • Quarterly Essay launched in March 2001 and remains Australia's most influential long-form political journal, published quarterly by Black Inc.
  • Bernard Keane's Lies and Falsehoods was published as Quarterly Essay 82 in 2021, during Scott Morrison's final term as Prime Minister.
  • Hugh White's Power Shift (Quarterly Essay 39, 2010) predicted China's rise and Australia's strategic dilemma five years before Xi Jinping consolidated power.
  • George Megalogenis won the Walkley Book Award in 2013 for The Australian Moment, which expanded themes from his 2010 Quarterly Essay Trivial Pursuit.
  • James Brown, a former Australian Army officer, published Firing Line as Quarterly Essay 62 in 2016, examining Australia's post-2001 military commitments.
  • Robert Bollard's In the Shadow of Gallipoli (2013) reframes Australia's WWI experience beyond the ANZAC legend, covering Palestine, Mesopotamia, and the home front.

Lies and Falsehoods: The Morrison Government and the New Culture of Deceit — Bernard Keane

A forensic takedown of Morrison's systematic dishonesty, published before the full ugliness of the secret ministries came to light.

Keane's essay is a prosecutor's brief: chapter and verse of Morrison's lies, from Robodebt denials to the "I don't hold a hose, mate" Hawaii defence. Published in 2021, it predates the Solicitor-General's opinion on Morrison's secret ministries — which only proves Keane's thesis. Morrison didn't just bend truth; he weaponised opacity. Keane writes with Crikey's house style: caustic, evidence-heavy, zero patience for spin. This is the preloved copy you lend to mates still claiming "both sides do it." The foxing on your copy's pages won't make the receipts any less damning. Explore our current copy of Lies and Falsehoods or browse more Politics & Current Affairs books at Patina.

Power Shift: Australia's Future Between Washington and Beijing — Hugh White

The 2010 essay that predicted Australia's entire China dilemma — and we still haven't answered White's question.

White's argument is stark: as China's economy overtakes America's, Australia must choose between a fading hegemon and a rising autocracy — or carve a middle path neither will forgive. Published as Quarterly Essay 39 in 2010, before AUKUS, before the Belt and Road blow-up, before Huawei bans, Power Shift reads like a prophecy we ignored. White is a former Deputy Secretary of Defence and professor of strategic studies at ANU; he knows where the bodies are buried. The essay's clinical tone makes its fatalism more chilling: we're trapped between a partner who won't defend Taiwan and an adversary who won't tolerate neutrality. Fourteen years on, we're still pretending there's a safe option. Explore our current copy of Power Shift or browse more Politics & Current Affairs books at Patina.

Firing Line: Australia's Path to War — James Brown

A former Army officer asks why Australia reflexively joins America's wars — and gets no satisfying answer.

Brown's 2016 essay dissects Australia's post-9/11 military commitments: Afghanistan, Iraq, the Middle East air campaign. His thesis is brutal in its simplicity: we deployed because the Americans asked, not because Cabinet rigorously assessed national interest. Brown served in Iraq; he's not a pacifist. He's a sceptic of reflexive ANZUS loyalty. Firing Line (Quarterly Essay 62) names the politicians who waved troops off without hard questions, the generals who confused alliance management with strategy, the media cycle that punished dissent as disloyalty. It's a short book — under 100 pages — that lands like a gut punch. Your preloved copy may have a creased spine from someone gripping it too hard. Explore our current copy of Firing Line or browse more Politics & Current Affairs books at Patina.

Trivial Pursuit: Leadership and the End of the Reform Era — George Megalogenis

Megalogenis mourns the Hawke-Keating-Howard reform consensus and asks why we're now too scared to fix anything hard.

Published as Quarterly Essay 40 in 2010 — the same year as White's Power Shift — Megalogenis traces how Australian politics shifted from big reform (tariff cuts, float the dollar, GST) to petty culture wars. He pins the decay to leadership churn: six prime ministers in a decade will do that. Megalogenis, then Fairfax's senior political writer, expanded this essay into The Australian Moment (2012), which won the Walkley Book Award. But the Quarterly Essay distills his argument to a sharp 25,000 words: we've abandoned reform because focus groups punish courage and Newspoll rules Cabinet. Your secondhand copy will smell faintly of disappointment — or maybe that's just Australian politics since 2010. Explore our current copy of Trivial Pursuit or browse more Politics & Current Affairs books at Patina.

In the Shadow of Gallipoli: The Hidden Story of Australia in WWI — Robert Bollard

A corrective to the ANZAC legend: Australia's WWI reached Egypt, Palestine, Mesopotamia, and the home front — Gallipoli was just the bloody prologue.

Bollard's 2013 book strips the gauze off the ANZAC myth. Yes, Gallipoli mattered — 8,000 Australians died there — but more Australians fought on the Western Front, in Sinai, at Beersheba. Bollard covers the Light Horse in Palestine, the conscription referendums that tore the home front apart, the 1916 Battle of Fromelles (5,533 Australian casualties in 24 hours — our worst day). He writes as a military historian, not a mythbuster, but the effect is the same: we've fetishised one campaign and forgotten a war. This is political history in the sense that wars reveal how nations see themselves — and in 1914, Australia saw itself as Britain's loyal son. White, Brown, and Keane would recognise the pattern. Explore our current copy of In the Shadow of Gallipoli or browse more Politics & Current Affairs books at Patina.

As of June 2026, these five titles anchor Patina's Australian political analysis collection — the preloved copies that explain how we got here. From Morrison's deceit to Menzies' Cold War reflex, the through-line is clear: Australia mistakes alliance loyalty for strategy, and we're still paying the tab. Shop all Politics & Current Affairs books at Patina Paperbacks →

Where can I buy secondhand copies of Quarterly Essay back issues in Sydney?

Patina Paperbacks stocks rotating preloved Quarterly Essay titles, including the four featured here (Keane's Lies and Falsehoods, White's Power Shift, Brown's Firing Line, and Megalogenis' Trivial Pursuit). We ship Australia-wide, but if you're in Sydney's Inner West, you can collect from our Marrickville warehouse by arrangement. Check our Politics & Current Affairs collection for current stock.

Are Quarterly Essays worth reading years after publication?

Honestly, yes — especially the ones that predicted mess we're still living through. White's 2010 Power Shift reads like it was written last year; Megalogenis' 2010 Trivial Pursuit explains why Albanese's government is too cautious to fix housing or climate. Political analysis ages better than daily news because the structural problems don't change — just the names and scandals.

What makes Bernard Keane's book on Morrison different from standard political commentary?

Keane isn't opinion — he's a legal case. Lies and Falsehoods catalogs Morrison's statements, cross-references them with public records, and proves systematic dishonesty. It's forensic, not rhetorical. Published before the secret ministries scandal broke, the essay now reads as underselling Morrison's deceit. That's the value of holding a 2021 text in 2025: you can see how right Keane was, and how much worse it got.

Why does Patina stock military history like In the Shadow of Gallipoli alongside political analysis?

Because wars are political decisions in uniform. Bollard's WWI book and Brown's Firing Line ask the same question a century apart: why does Australia follow great powers into wars that don't serve our interests? The ANZAC legend is political mythology; understanding 1914 clarifies why we're still doing it in 2025. Plus, Bollard writes beautifully — this isn't a slog.

Which of these five books should I read first if I'm new to Australian political history?

Start with Megalogenis' Trivial Pursuit — it's the Rosetta Stone for post-2000 Australian politics. Then jump to Keane's Lies and Falsehoods for the Morrison case study, White's Power Shift for the China bind, and Brown's Firing Line for the war reflex. Save Bollard's In the Shadow of Gallipoli for last: it'll reframe everything else as a pattern, not a crisis.

Back to blog